XII
There are many connections within these three stories. The first and third story relate in their use of calls. One call tells the wife to act. She sets fire to the fat and throws it on the introducers, which enables her and her child to escape. In the second story, the bobcat startles the world with its call. Also, fire occurs in the first two stories. In one instance, fire is used to fend enemies off a home… when the wife sets fire to the fat. In the other, the fire destroys a sacred tipi. Fire can be used to protect and destroy. It can burn; just as well as it can cook food to feed hungry mouths. Whoever holds power over the fire can use it for their benefit or destruction.
XIV
In the last story, there is an abundance of vivid imagery. Nature is being used as protection here – in the form of a shelter. Nature can be both beautiful and devastating. I find this to be a theme in many of the stories throughout this The Way to Rainy Mountain. I believe that for this reason, the Natives were very much so concerned with pleasing their higher power… performing sacrifices, ceremonies, and such.
XV
This story made me laugh pretty hard… the first story. A man is sleeping with one of your wives. You shoot him with an arrow. He succeeds in stealing her away. After fifteen years, the man and woman come back… you great them, tell the man that you will be brothers… and proceed to give him six of your horses. Why does this story make no sense to me? Is there suppose to be some kind of moral here, or is it just a story to entertain?
XVI
In the first story, the bull with the steel horns is hit in the flesh of the hoof .The man uses his brain over brawn to wiggle himself out of a sticky situation. This theme is also seen in XII-the first story. XVI reminds me of a Greek myth – Achilles.
In the second story of XVI, the wild strain is gone from the buffalo. Dogs have become so domesticated now that if we were to release them, they would not know how to fend for themselves. In the case of the buffalo, the old men still find the sport in killing them, but maybe not as much sport.
XVII
She had blue eyes.
XIX
White men took away their main means of getting around, of hunting – their livelihood. They slaughtered the horses not to use themselves, but to kill and break their spirits.
XX
First story -This might be my favorite story so far. The hunting horse died of shame. You can’t tame a wild heart. You can’t fence in something that is meant to be wild and free.
In the second and third stories, the horse is a huge sacrifice. “If you will give me my life and the lives of my family, I will give you the life of this black-eared horse.” Equivalent to one another?
XXI
Mammedaty – Maybe he was riding the fence of insanity – not between insanity and genius, but maybe just plain insanity. Nobody thought to question his sightings.
XXII
I’m always looking for deeper meaning. I’ve been trained to do so. I can’t find the deeper meaning in this story… the first story about Mammedaty and shooting the second horse on accident. Any thoughts?
In the second story, the loss of one horse was hard to bare. In a previous story we are told that 800 horses were killed, outright. These people probably felt like part of their soul was being crushed with every slaughter. Very sad.
XXIV
This story, as with most of the first stories that are italicized throughout the book contain little tales that have little or no evidence to support them, but they are all told like they are factual. These verbal stories and traditions are very important to the people.
I like learning about different cultures – their traditions, what they deem as important… etc. Overall, I enjoyed The Way to Rainy Mountain.
Sunday, February 28, 2010
The Way to Rainy Mountain 2nd Half Readings
Sunday, February 21, 2010
Momaday Video
"The Kiowa's were very good at stealing people... as well as horses." :) haha.
Millie Dergan - A kiowa captive. He did not know Millie Dergan's past, but he made a past for her through his poem. It commemorates Millie... vaguely reminds me of a story by Poe - Man in the Crowd or Man of the Crowd - I can't remember. A man sits and watches people pass by and by their outfit, he makes judgements about them. He almost creates a past for some people, for people he has not had much contact with.
Responding to Momaday - does it sound like he has a certain accent? Or was he just very formally educated? Just a thought.
HAHAHAHAHA. Please forward to 12:30-12:40 on this video. I know we sometimes get caught in our reading, but be for real. This man extremely intelligent, I don't see why he did this to himself.
When Momaday talks about his childhood - it makes me wish that I had a deep, rich culture... something heavily routed in tradition like the Native Americans had... or I wish that my parents would have told me more about where I came from.
Millie Dergan - A kiowa captive. He did not know Millie Dergan's past, but he made a past for her through his poem. It commemorates Millie... vaguely reminds me of a story by Poe - Man in the Crowd or Man of the Crowd - I can't remember. A man sits and watches people pass by and by their outfit, he makes judgements about them. He almost creates a past for some people, for people he has not had much contact with.
Responding to Momaday - does it sound like he has a certain accent? Or was he just very formally educated? Just a thought.
HAHAHAHAHA. Please forward to 12:30-12:40 on this video. I know we sometimes get caught in our reading, but be for real. This man extremely intelligent, I don't see why he did this to himself.
When Momaday talks about his childhood - it makes me wish that I had a deep, rich culture... something heavily routed in tradition like the Native Americans had... or I wish that my parents would have told me more about where I came from.
Thursday, February 18, 2010
VI & VII & VIII
Did anyone else find it funny - the song the grandmother spider sings to the sun's child. How comforting would it be to hear the words, "Your mother is dead and still you feed upon her breasts?" I don't know if that would make me fall asleep... just saying.
Through most of these paragraphs or little snipets, I see some kind of connection. I don't see that connection in VII - from talking about the boy throwing the ring up in the air that killed his mother, to only be cut into two and made into twins.... to more talk about horses... to someone swimming in the river and having a vision that is broken apart by a frog jumping. Any thoughts?
VIII - We give words power. We load words up. We assign names to objects and they stick. A chair isn't a chair... We gave that object the name - easier to identify. A slang word can have so much baggage attatched to it. Once used as an indifferent term, nigger is now seen as derogatory - as it should be. Saying the wrong word can break a politicians career. These are just some of the thoughts that were running through my mind when reading VIII - the last two paragraphs. Words hold so much meaning and power.
Through most of these paragraphs or little snipets, I see some kind of connection. I don't see that connection in VII - from talking about the boy throwing the ring up in the air that killed his mother, to only be cut into two and made into twins.... to more talk about horses... to someone swimming in the river and having a vision that is broken apart by a frog jumping. Any thoughts?
VIII - We give words power. We load words up. We assign names to objects and they stick. A chair isn't a chair... We gave that object the name - easier to identify. A slang word can have so much baggage attatched to it. Once used as an indifferent term, nigger is now seen as derogatory - as it should be. Saying the wrong word can break a politicians career. These are just some of the thoughts that were running through my mind when reading VIII - the last two paragraphs. Words hold so much meaning and power.
Fables
Most of the first stories in The Setting Out - (by first stories I mean the ones that are the first paragraph... that seem like an elder is telling them) remind me of Aesop's fables or any fable, really. They are short and to the point, and most have a clear moral. In story V, I'm not sure what the moral is here? Obey your husband...? Don't feel lonely for your family? I'm sorry. Maybe I'm just a young woman in the 21st century who does not get how this applies but? haha. I do get a correlation between the Sun being God and the woman being Eve. She touches the forbidden fruit, she opens pandoras box. Instead of becoming mortal, this woman is killed.
The Setting Out
I like the way this is set up. All of these books have given me a different way of reading - if that makes sense? It's not like we, as readers, haven't seen chapters have different narrators all strung together to make a complete story, but this is different. Each paragraph in setting out tells of a different story, with a link woven between them.
On the left page, there is an older story... when I read it I hear an old raspy chief telling of the times when he was younger - the older traditions.
The second paragraph seems like a more formal telling of an event that relates, but is not close to being the same.
With the third paragraph, I see a young person from the tribe, possibly present day, telling of her elders or what she sees now.
The Kiowas traditions still live on - but with a modern twist.
On the left page, there is an older story... when I read it I hear an old raspy chief telling of the times when he was younger - the older traditions.
The second paragraph seems like a more formal telling of an event that relates, but is not close to being the same.
With the third paragraph, I see a young person from the tribe, possibly present day, telling of her elders or what she sees now.
The Kiowas traditions still live on - but with a modern twist.
?Confused
Does anyone know what to make of "Looking back once, I saw the mountain and came away." I don't know if I'm just not getting something here? It reminds me of Poe in The Fall of the House of Usher... when he "I tell you now that she now stands without the door!" - why would he use WITHOUT.?!
So she looked back, saw the mountain, and came away... CAME AWAY? What does this mean? Where did they go then? Back towards the house... towards the mountain... am I not suppose to be taking this literally? Help. Please.
So she looked back, saw the mountain, and came away... CAME AWAY? What does this mean? Where did they go then? Back towards the house... towards the mountain... am I not suppose to be taking this literally? Help. Please.
Translations
Ne Me Quitte Pas
The narrator - yet to be identified, describes their grandmother's prayers... and how she knew not what she said, but she knew that it was something sad. She felt like she shouldn't be listening. There is a song that reminds me of this... I don't know what she's saying, but I know that the translation of the title means 'don't leave me.' The sadness in her voice almost makes me wanna cry. She goes through many emotions through the song, but sadness is very striking. At the end of the song, she isn't has hysterical. Maybe she's dealt with the loss of her lover? Not sure. Take a listen for yourself.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Q7w7gk1hQ
The narrator - yet to be identified, describes their grandmother's prayers... and how she knew not what she said, but she knew that it was something sad. She felt like she shouldn't be listening. There is a song that reminds me of this... I don't know what she's saying, but I know that the translation of the title means 'don't leave me.' The sadness in her voice almost makes me wanna cry. She goes through many emotions through the song, but sadness is very striking. At the end of the song, she isn't has hysterical. Maybe she's dealt with the loss of her lover? Not sure. Take a listen for yourself.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Q7w7gk1hQ
Ceremony
Tayo tries to fill a hole - an enormous gaping hole where Rocky had been with liquor... a place where the war had eaten away his sanity. More fragile than any of his friends - it left him vulnerable for depression... smarter than his buddies, he realizes that being like the white people isn't the solution - that reliving old war past times isn't going to make the past come back. It isn't going to make things better. What will it take to make Tayo whole again?
The poem about the people beginning to believe in magic (which was all a trick in the first place) and neglecting everything... Did anyone else think that the poem lacked rhythm? I guess I'm so use to reading poems that have iambic pentameter or something along those lines... that it has become hard to read free-verse. I like how this poem correlates to Rocky seeing his family's traditions as foolish. The foolishness of the people in the poem makes everyone suffer. What does this say about Rocky?
The poem about the people beginning to believe in magic (which was all a trick in the first place) and neglecting everything... Did anyone else think that the poem lacked rhythm? I guess I'm so use to reading poems that have iambic pentameter or something along those lines... that it has become hard to read free-verse. I like how this poem correlates to Rocky seeing his family's traditions as foolish. The foolishness of the people in the poem makes everyone suffer. What does this say about Rocky?
Sunday, February 14, 2010
Friday, February 12, 2010
Color/Winds
I found a link that elaborates on the colors in the Native American culture. They relate to the winds - North, South, East, West. I wish I would have known about this before I started reading The Ceremony. Wind is mentioned many times throughout the book, and doing an analysis of the colors relating to the wind would be interesting.
http://users.ap.net/~chenae/spirit.html
http://users.ap.net/~chenae/spirit.html
Sunday, February 7, 2010
Reservation
The land on the reservation is in a severe drought. The land throughout the entire state is probably in a similiar state, but I always feel like everything is worse on the reservation... not from what the author is revealing to the reader, but more what I've learned about the reservation land - how it was broken up - etc. They were given the least fertile pieces of land, but when the government found that there was something on the land they wanted - they were relocated. The gold in the Black Hills - etc.
Effects of War
My dad was involved in Vietnam. My mom said he was different after. I've only known that 'different' dad. Like many, he doesn't talk about it much.
Like Harley, my dad never use to drink until after the war. Drug and and alcohol dependency was a major problem after Vietnam... this is probably the case for every war. The tramtic experiences that Tayo describes, and the intense psychological toll that it took on him... I could see why men are driven to extremes.
Tayo, Harley, Emo, Josiah, Rocky - I wanna look more into these names... good authors choose every word they write for a purpose, the same goes for character names. I'm curious as to why these? Anyone have any thoughts?
Like Harley, my dad never use to drink until after the war. Drug and and alcohol dependency was a major problem after Vietnam... this is probably the case for every war. The tramtic experiences that Tayo describes, and the intense psychological toll that it took on him... I could see why men are driven to extremes.
Tayo, Harley, Emo, Josiah, Rocky - I wanna look more into these names... good authors choose every word they write for a purpose, the same goes for character names. I'm curious as to why these? Anyone have any thoughts?
Wednesday, February 3, 2010
Ceremony - Opening thoughts
I was particularly being drawn to the color words in Ceremony. An over abundance of color occurs when the narrator speaks about Japan. In contrast, when talking about home, the scheme turns to mostly gray or black... bleak. Silko may be aiming at irony here. With all the death that surrounds him, the colors are vibrant... or maybe, maybe all the color has been sucked out of him... all the life - after having fought in battle - having seen the life being sucked from the Japanese and his fellow soliders.
Also, there is a poem that appears about a woman who occupies her time by taking baths, while the other works hard in the fields. The sister that works curses her sister for taking baths all day. She goes back to her orginal place, down below... and the rains stop. This reminds me of a greek myth... involving Persephone.
"Beautiful daughter of Zeus and Demeter; sometimes considered an Olympian. While gathering flowers in a field one day, Persephone was abducted to the Underworld by Hades, who arose in his chariot from a fissure in the ground. Demeter, goddess of the harvest, was heartbroken, and while she wandered the length and breadth of the earth in search of her daughter, the crops withered and it became perpetual winter. At length Hades was persuaded to surrender Persephone for one half of every year, the spring and summer seasons when flowers bloom and the earth bears fruit once more. The half year that Persephone spends in the Underworld as Hades' queen coincides with the barren season. The heroes Peirithous and Theseus attempted to abduct Persephone and bring her back to the land of the living."
- http://www.mythweb.com/encyc/entries/persephone.html
Every culture has their own creation stories... their own reasoning for the seasons, etc. It's interesting to find such a close relation here.
Also, there is a poem that appears about a woman who occupies her time by taking baths, while the other works hard in the fields. The sister that works curses her sister for taking baths all day. She goes back to her orginal place, down below... and the rains stop. This reminds me of a greek myth... involving Persephone.
"Beautiful daughter of Zeus and Demeter; sometimes considered an Olympian. While gathering flowers in a field one day, Persephone was abducted to the Underworld by Hades, who arose in his chariot from a fissure in the ground. Demeter, goddess of the harvest, was heartbroken, and while she wandered the length and breadth of the earth in search of her daughter, the crops withered and it became perpetual winter. At length Hades was persuaded to surrender Persephone for one half of every year, the spring and summer seasons when flowers bloom and the earth bears fruit once more. The half year that Persephone spends in the Underworld as Hades' queen coincides with the barren season. The heroes Peirithous and Theseus attempted to abduct Persephone and bring her back to the land of the living."
- http://www.mythweb.com/encyc/entries/persephone.html
Every culture has their own creation stories... their own reasoning for the seasons, etc. It's interesting to find such a close relation here.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
